|
Two
reviews of Viking Clothing from Amazon:
Thought-provoking
survey of a specialized field, July 6, 2006
By Catherine Raymond
Ewing’s book is not designed as a how-to or a basic reference
for reenactors. Instead, it surveys the current knowledge and
scholarly thinking about Viking-era costume and challenges the reader
to consider different theories that are consistent with the evidence.
An enjoyable, educational read for costume-enthusiasts and
recreationists willing to think outside the box instead of looking for
easy answers.
Not
for the amateur re-enactor, September 17, 2006
By Terry Broberg-Swangin
Thor Ewing’s book is well written and it does a good job of
laying out the current state of Norse costume research.
However, this is not a book for the amateur re-enactor who
wants to make a “Viking costume.” It will
not give you step-by-step instructions on how to make a
“Viking costume.”
In many ways, the book raises more questions than it answers and I
forsee it sparking some excellent and spirited discussions among those
of us who have been researching Norse costume for many years.
It's a fine book which has given me a great deal to think about and I
am truly glad I purchased it. But, if you are new or fairly
new to the Society for Creative Anachronism or other Dark Ages
re-enactment groups, I would pass on this book until you have done more
research or you could end up very confused.
|